01
N.D. Texas rules for What If Holdings in Starling, rejecting reliance on other courts' TCPA interpretations
In Starling v. What If Holdings, 2026 WL 3536298 (N.D. Tex. Nov. 16, 2026), the court found that relying solely on consistency with other court opinions or agency interpretation, without examining the statute's text, does not amount to independent interpretation. TCPAWorld's coverage calls this a win for What If Holdings and says it creates a roadmap for similar TCPA SMS defenses in other courts around the country.
Why it matters: If other courts adopt this approach, businesses defending TCPA text-message suits may have a new line of argument that does not depend on what other districts have already decided. That could affect how SMS compliance risk is weighed for anyone texting prospects.